Author: Ward Chanley
Why is it offensive when cis men say they are lesbians trapped in a man’s body?
This was an answer over on Quora.
Why is it offensive when cis men say they are lesbians trapped in a man’s body?
For the same reasons it would annoy or offend my trans friends if I described myself as a straight woman trapped in a manâs body.
Iâm gay. I donât experience gender dysphoria.
I donât know what that feels like. I will never, ever know what that feels like. Itâs not mine to make casual, offhand remarks about. Itâs a painful experience that isnât mine, that I only ever know about through inference. Iâve had friends compare it to various things, but none of that really tells me what the experience is. It just sort of tells me what some of that experience is like.
But I can talk, all day long about swimming. That will never be the same thing as experiencing the act of swimming.
In much the same way that I canât ever really get a straight person to understand homophobia, the lived daily reality of it in the way I experience it, I will never, ever understand gender dysphoria. Ever.
I can sympathize, but I will never be able to actually empathize.
I am not straight. I am not a woman. I am nothing trapped in some other body. Iâm a cis man; Iâm a gay man. I sympathize with my friends when they say that gender dysphoria is painful – painful enough to risk all of their relationships by coming out and transitioning. That I do know something about, because Iâm queer. We can share that.
But that doesnât mean I understand dysphoria, and itâs hurtful for me to treat it like a casual joke as if I do.
How do you feel about the term “fag hag”?
This was an answer over on Quora.
I have friends who embrace the term, and friends who donât. Itâs up to them; it isnât up to me. If Iâm with friends who self-describe as faghags, we all use it – much like gay men who are comfortable with each other will call each other faggot and queen. (I do this, too, depending on the social circle Iâm with.)
But if somebody dislikes it, I wonât use it with them.
I donât feel like itâs inherently offensive, just because itâs historically been a slur, or connected to a slur. I think thereâs power in reclaiming slurs across the board.
But itâs not up to me to tell a specific woman itâs okay because I think itâs âreclaiming.â
Itâs only useful in that way if itâs chosen as such.
Madonna: âLetâs face it, Iâm a big âole faghag.â
Madonna shouldnât call herself what we all know she is? Eh. I donât see it. Others will object, and thatâs fine, but if itâs something we choose, and embrace, why is it insulting? Because the word âhagâ has shitty connotations? Because âfagâ does? Okay. But thereâs something really amazing, and particularly special about the women who hang around in the gay scene, the women who are there because they specifically want to be, because theyâre us, too. If they want to embrace âfaghagâ in much the way I embrace âfag,â I think itâs fantastic. If you donât, you donât. Thatâs okay.
Why can black people use the “N-word” in casual conversation, but white people should not?
This turned into one of my semi-popular answers over on Quora.
The reality youâre going to have to face is that not all words are open to you.
You donât get to call me âQueenâ or âfaggot,â even if my friends get to.
You and I donât get to call trans women âtranny,â even if other trans people get to.
Not all terms are available to you. Thatâs a simple fact. Get used to it.
You donât own the emotional reality of those terms, for those people. They own them. You didnât grow up hearing âfaggotâ used as a slur and knowing, to the bones, that that was directed at you. You didnât grow up a gender-variant gay boy hearing âfaggotâ and related slurs the way they were used to slur me.
I get to reclaim those terms, for my use. They arenât for you. They donât describe you. Theyâre not open to you.
Similarly, you arenât black. You havenât grown up hearing shit like, âthe only good nigger is a dead nigger,â or âyou know, I donât mind blacks, itâs the niggers I canât stand.â
The emotional reality of those terms isnât something you ever experienced, and it isnât something you ever will experience, because you are not that person.
Just as you arenât gay, if youâre a straight guy, wondering why itâs all right when my friends call me a fag, but itâs not okay if you do it.
Itâs not okay.
Some words arenât open to you. Thatâs all you really need to understand.
If that feels unfair to you, try to imagine living in a world where you arenât entitled to extra shit just because your skin is brown.
How do guys become gay?
This was an answer over on Quora.
By recognizing that they already are gay.
Before I could put a finger (teehee!) on how I specifically felt different from other, ânormalâ boys, I knew I was different. Apparently, as a tot, I didn’t go through an âeeeew, girls have cootiesâ phase. I was friends with several of the neighborhood girls.
They were awesome. They cared not a whit that I was a boy and was every bit as interested in their dolls and silly plastic jewelry as they were. (Mom put a stop to that, however. I may well have been the most obviously pink boy ever, but that didn’t mean she wouldn’t try to cover over all of that with liberal coats of any other color.)
A little later, when folks would talk to me about when I grew up and got married, and had kids of my own⌠I knew, somewhere deep that wouldn’t happen. My nine and ten year old crushes were all boys. My fourth grade male teacher was awesome in ways I had already learned I needed to keep to myself. A fourth grade boy with a crush on his female teacher is regarded as cuteâŚbut his male teacher? Don’t ever let that slip.
A short while later, when the hormones and adolescence kicked in, that interest in boys became overtly sexual. I wasn’t just the somewhat fey, pink boy who didn’t enjoy âboy thingsâ…I was gay like a box oâ Christmas lights. Visible from space gay. Diamond tiara and combat boots gay.
Pretty freaking gay.
But I didn’t become anything so much as realize, and eventually accept that I was, and had been all along.
Does your cat meow back to you when you talk to it?
This was an answer over on Quora.
It totally depends on which of our cats I’m talking to.
If it’s Jasper, he talks to everyone. He talks back if you talk to him, and he’s quite happy to initiate a conversation. He’ll talk to new people, people he knows, the bird on the feeder outside, the bathroom door when it’s closed, some random spot on the wall⌠He’s chatty, that one.
Orlando only ever talks when he’s hungry, but he’s constantly hungry. If either of us set foot anywhere that might eventually lead to the kitchen, he heads straight for his bowl and announces its emptiness. If you talk to him, he will look you in the face and tell you again. And again. And again, just in case you didn’t get it the first 167 times.
Paco was a chatty cat when he first came to us, but he’s quieted down now that he’s settled into our house. About the only time he talks now is when we’re getting out of the shower, and I suspect that’s more about the shower door being closed, than anything else. (Himself does not approve.)
Iggy ? rarely ever talked. If she was vocal, something was wrong.
What is the appropriate bedtime for a 17 year old?
This was an answer over on Quora.
Mom sat us both down when we turned 16.
âIf you’re old enough to drive, you’re old enough to get yourself out of trouble.â
What she meant was: we were out of the house, on our own, at least as far as getting to school or jobs were concerned. (I don’t drive, but the conversation was largely the same.) We each knew – to a certainty – that our mother meant it when she said, starting at about age 13, âif you get yourself in trouble, I will not bail you out. If you drive drunk, you’re spending the night in jail, or until your hearing. If you get someone pregnant, you will support your child, under your roof. If you steal or do drugs, and you get caught, I will not bail you out. I will visit you in jail.â
We didn’t test her. We’d been raised from infancy that that particular tone of voice meant she wasn’t kidding around, and she meant *every last word *of what she was telling us.
Neither of us were stupid enough to call her bluff, because we *knew *she wasn’t bluffing.
Now: bedtimes and curfews. Once we were old enough to drive, or get ourselves around, hard curfews ended. We could work until 10, hang around with friends until 11 or midnight (or later) but we weren’t to wake her or cause a disturbance coming home. We were expected to maintain our grades, and hold a job such that we could continue paying room and board.
If we screwed around with either of those, she might have instituted a curfew, but I doubt it. She was pretty much set on the idea that we were either responsible teenagers, or not, but it was up to us to manage our time, keep our grades up and keep a job.
When J. blew off his first job and lost it, mom kept a running tally, and he was to pay back rent when he had a paycheck again. (And again, she wasn’t kidding around.)
At 17 your ability to parent her like a six year old has ceased. Your daughter is nearly an adult, and will be one inside of a year.
You need to start preparing her to be one. You need to have started years earlier, but if you expect to keep her following rules that might make sense for younger children, you’re not doing that. She needs some adult expectations and with those, some adult consequences for failing to meet them. If she isn’t waking up for school, that is *her problem. *Make sure your 17 old is prepared to move out, or she never will.
Why am I progressive?
This was an answer I posted over on Quora.
Largely because the things I care about, and the policies that I think make a better, more functional society for nearly everyone are labelled âprogressive.â
If my general political goals (briefly summarizing, thatâs prioritizing environmental protection, global climate change, feminism, LGBTQ equality, racial justice, economic equality, and a complete overhaul of our foreign policy to stress human rights over US imperialism) were labelled âneoconservative,â or âjuniper berries,â Iâd use those labels instead.
I donât particularly care about the label. Itâs useful to have something other than âliberal,â when a small minority of European Quorans get pedantic about their liberalism being more or less equivalent to our libertarianism, but Iâm not attached to the label per se.
If youâre asking why I care about those things, regardless of the label, itâs because Iâm of the firm belief, based on what I can see with my own eyes, that societies that prioritize these things work better, for the vast majority of the populace, than societies that donât.
What Other People Think
The US has a debt to the Colombian people
This is why we need to radically reconsider our drug policy, and take all necessary steps, including legalization, to end the “War on Drugs.”
The U.S. has a debt to the Colombian people because it also played a dirty role in this cruel war. The U.S. trained and supplied the Colombian military with billions of our tax dollars as it committed human rights abuses against its own people. We know that the so-called âWar on Drugsâ was really a war on our people in the United States and in Colombia.
https://ajamubaraka.squarespace.com/blog/2016/8/31/statement-on-colombia-peace-agreement




